On 30 October, Antigua and Barbuda’s Prime Minister Gaston Browne wrote to the European Commission with an offer: To end the country’s Citizenship by Investment Programme by the end of 2030.
The offer is conditional. Antigua asks for a longer transition than the June 2028 date set by Brussels, as well as financial and technical support to cushion the economic impact. Formal replies to Brussels were due by 12 November, and Antigua’s Citizenship by Investment Unit said that day that it continues to accept applications.
Until Antigua’s letter, I was confident that the Caribbean governments would not agree to close their programmes. On 13 November, Saint Kitts and Nevis followed: Prime Minister Terrance Drew announced that his country will wind down its programme on a timeline his government is now negotiating with the European Union (EU).
I remain convinced that closure is the wrong answer.
A simple choice on paper
Under the revised EU visa suspension mechanism, the very existence of an investor citizenship programme can justify suspending visa-free travel. So each government can either phase out its programme and preserve Schengen access for its citizens, or retain the programme and risk a visa requirement.
That requirement would hit ordinary citizens first: the islanders who travel to Europe to study or see family, and no government can dismiss that cost. In practice, the two sides of the scale are far from equal.
Who applies
Many of the investors we advise already have US or EU citizenship, or a nationality with visa-free access to the Schengen Area. Europe was never their reason to apply. They come for a plan B for their families, for business in the region, for diversification of residence and citizenship. A Schengen visa requirement for Caribbean citizens would barely touch their plans.
Investors without such access by default increasingly build a two-part strategy. Caribbean citizenship serves as their plan B, while a residence permit in a European country gives them a legal basis to live in or travel to Europe. For them, the EU’s pressure is a reason to add European residence, not to drop the Caribbean.
Our consultations show the same picture. Before the Commission’s letters in June, about three in four citizenship enquiries we received concerned Caribbean programmes. Since then, the share is closer to two in three. Interest dipped. It did not disappear.
What would closure cost?
For the islands, the arithmetic is much harder. According to the International Monetary Fund, government revenue from citizenship by investment averaged about 6.5% of gross domestic product (GDP) across the five programme countries from 2019 to 2023. In 2023, it made up nearly a third of their total non-grant revenue.
Antigua and Barbuda alone collected about US$58 million from its programme in 2025, and ending it would erase more than half of the country’s projected primary surplus this year, according to an analyst quoted by Reuters. Programme inflows in Saint Kitts and Nevis and Dominica have at times exceeded 10% of GDP.
No small island economy replaces this kind of revenue quickly without cuts its citizens would feel directly. Mr Browne’s request for a long transition and EU support is, in itself, an acknowledgement of that.
The groundwork already exists
Since 2023, the five countries have agreed a common minimum investment of US$200,000, introduced mandatory applicant interviews, begun sharing information on refused applications and worked towards a joint regional regulator.
This is the language Brussels understands: Stronger screening, systematic exclusion of sanctioned individuals, transparency. In my view, building on that system is a better answer than switching off a major source of revenue.
According to Inter Bellum News, the Commission has called the regional regulator “an important regional development.” A Commission spokesperson told the outlet on 12 November that “the details of such a phase-out are still under discussion.”
The only constant is change
Antigua’s offer is a starting point for negotiation, not a final decision, and there is no sign yet that the Commission accepts the 2030 timeline. Mr Browne also said Antigua was coordinating with its neighbours on a common regional position.
The Saint Kitts and Nevis programme has no closing date yet, and Mr Drew said it will accept applications until his government agrees a final date with Brussels. Grenada’s Prime Minister Dickon Mitchell said his government “would like to maintain both” its programme and Schengen access.
Saint Lucia confirmed on 9 November that it has sent its written reply, though it has not made the contents public. Dominica, which pledged to “communicate further” with the EU by 12 November, has not disclosed whether it did.
We will watch closely how the Commission responds in its next visa suspension report, due in December.
For investors, the message is to plan with care. Programme conditions can change, and no one can promise that today’s terms will last. Even so, I believe demand for Caribbean citizenship will remain for as long as the programmes accept applications, as one part of a wider plan rather than a single ticket to Europe.
The views expressed are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect those of IMI.




