Offering options to your clients in order for them to meet their immigration goals is one of the most important services you can offer. To that end, it’s crucial to understand the different investment options around the world and in the United States in particular.
For your clients who are interested in living and working in the US, sometimes the options don’t look very appealing. For Indian and Chinese nationals, in particular, the wait time can be more than a decade; and as most of you have read, the cost will be (in November 2019) overwhelming.
Many of you may have heard about the E2 visa – the lesser-known US investment visa – but don’t know much about how it compares to the EB-5 investor visa. This article will dive into the E2 and compare it to the EB-5 from the point of view of meeting clients’ goals.
EB-5 vs. E2 Per-Country Limits
- EB-5: Annually 10,000 worldwide, with no more than 7.1% of those issued to nationals of one country. The per-country limit and overall worldwide limit for this visa have been problematic for Chinese, Vietnamese, and Indian investors.
- E2: None. There were more than 40,000 E2 visas issued in 2018, and that number is likely to rise. Thankfully, there is no per-country limit and, in fact, no overall limit to the number of E2 visas that can be issued in a year.
EB-5 vs. E2 Nationality of Investor
- EB-5: Main applicant can be a national of any country in the world (China, Vietnam and India are currently backlogged). The country of origin/nationality for EB-5 purposes is typically determined by country of birth. There is a possibility to be “chargeable” to another country if the applicant is married to someone who was born in another country. But, simply having a passport from another country isn’t going to help side-step the line.
- E2: Main applicant must be a national of a treaty country. The E2 visa can be issued to anyone who has a passport from a treaty country. (NOTE – neither the spouse nor the children of the investor need to have a treaty country passport.) There is no required waiting time after being granted a treaty country passport in order to apply for the E2 visa. The Grenada passport is a great option for those who wish to apply for the E2 visa but have a non-treaty country passport.
EB-5 vs. E2 Time Frame
- EB-5: 2-14 years. For nationals of China, India, and Vietnam, the wait can be more than a decade. Even for nationals of non-backlogged countries, the wait will likely be a minimum of two years. That’s quite a bit of time to have money tied up and still have no legal basis to live and work in the US. Also, for those clients who are moving to the US in order to further their children’s education, waiting for years may not be a realistic solution.
- E2: 3-6 months. The E2 visa is a non-immigrant visa (more about that later), so the process is simpler and faster. In fact, the Department of State review time (after applying but before the interview) varies from 2-10 weeks in most instances. From the date of the interview, it will take about one week to get the E2 visa affixed to the investor’s passport. The longest part of this process is waiting for the client to gather documents.
EB-5 vs. E2 Cost
- EB-5: $900,000-$1,800,000 (as of November 2019). As we all know, the EB-5 will increase to a minimum investment of $900,000 starting in November. Although the EB-5 is still one of the most reasonably-priced residency programs, when the minimum investment nearly doubles soon, this may be out of reach for many clients. And, for those who are able to afford $900,000, they may not be willing to part with it for years.
- E2: $100,000-$400,000. In fact, there is no minimum amount of investment needed in order to get an E2 visa. The amount of the investment simply needs to be “substantial” considering the type and location of the business. (As I tell my clients, a night club in Manhattan will require much more investment than a family accounting firm in Lincoln, Nebraska.) With so little guidance, it’s difficult to tell any client with certainty that they have spent enough in order to secure the E2 visa. That said, we know how much will not be enough to secure the visa, and that is generally anything less than $100,000. (That said, there is an exception to every rule. I have had several clients get the E2 visa for an investment less than $100,000.) The “substantial” amount invested is not tied to any geography or designated area.
EB-5 vs. E2 Business Flexibility
- EB-5: In theory can be any business, but the investor does not have to work in the business. In theory, the EB-5 visa can be attained with an investment in any business. That said, according to USCIS, historically, nearly all EB-5 visas issued were through Regional Centers. There are a wide variety of options, but they typically fall under the heading of major real estate development. For those who are brave enough to do a direct investment, they will be running their business from afar in most cases. At a minimum, this will be nerve-wracking; and in the worst scenarios, employees could run the business into the ground before the EB-5 visa is approved. In addition, the number of employees should make sense to the business. That said, once the investor gets his/her green card, the options for work are limitless. This likely has much appeal to the investors.
- E2: Can be any business that is 1) legal 2) for profit. The investor must work in the business and will have no authorization to work elsewhere. There is almost no limit to the type of business an E2 investor can start or buy. The investor could start a business from scratch, purchase an existing business or franchise or purchase shares in an existing business. The most important decision a client can make is about his/her interest in the business. The E2 visa requires the investor to “direct and develop” the business; so the investor will need to work in the business on a daily/frequent basis. In addition, the business for which the investor is approved is printed on the E2 visa. No other work is authorized.
EB-5 vs. E2 Travel Flexibility
- EB-5: After the visa is approved, very flexible. Once the EB-5 is issued, the investor will have permanent residency in the US. This means that he/she can travel in and out of the US at will for any period of time. (CAVEAT – Green cardholders must be in the US at least six months out of the year or may have immigration troubles.)
- E2: Varies depending upon nationality. Each treaty country has a different agreement with the United States. As a result, travel flexibility varies greatly. Countries with the most flexible visa (including Grenada) will allow multiple entries/exits from the United States for up to five years before the visa needs to be renewed. The countries with the least flexible visas only allow one entry to the US and no exits from the US. This means the visa holder will get the visa, come to the United States and have status in the US for two years. If he/she leaves the US, he/she will need to reapply at the US consulate in the home country in order to return.
Hundreds of firms can assist with applications to the EB-5 and E-2 visa programs. To see which ones, visit the Residence and Citizenship by Investment Company Directory.
EB-5 vs. E2 Long-Term residency in the US
- EB-5: Green card/permanent residency. Once granted the EB-5, the investor will be a permanent resident of the United States. The investor will have all of the freedoms associated with “green card” holders. After five years of permanent resident status, the investor may apply to become a US citizen. Green card holders have freedom of travel (as long as the investor is still living in the US) and freedom to work anywhere or go to school.
- E2: Renewable indefinitely as long as business qualifies, but never becomes permanent residency and never leads to citizenship. This is one of the major drawbacks to investors. Even if the investor has been in the US for 20 years, created 100 jobs and generated $10,000,000 in tax revenue, once he/she sells the business or retires, he/she needs to the leave the US immediately. The E2 visa is no longer valid. Of course, there are strategic ways to get the E2 and eventually get a different type of status that will allow for the green card. The E2 visa will never “turn into” a green card.
EB-5 vs. E2 Children
- EB-5: Children can come as long as they don’t “age out”. Unfortunately, the backlogs on EB-5 petitions can be so long that by the time the visa number is current, the child may no longer be eligible for a green card. The date of filing and the child’s birthdate are incredibly important in figuring out if the child will be eligible to get the green card. The Child Status Protection Act can be somewhat complicated, and dates should be confirmed with the attorney helping your client.E2:
- Children can come as dependents until 21st birthday. For those who are most interested in sending their children to school in the US, the E2 visa is ideal. The child will be an E2 visa derivative and can attend school in the US until his/her 21st birthday. On that date, the child will need to get a different type of visa or will need to return to his/her home country. (The most common type of visa the child gets at age 21 is the F1, which is a student visa.)
The differences between the EB-5 and E2 visas are significant. The series comparing the two will continue in the near future.